Essay by Delia Falconer
In October 1945, just three months after Japan’s surrender ended Australia’s role in the Second World War, the Sydney Morning Herald announced that it had set aside £30,000 to stimulate the development of our art and literature, which included a £2,000 prize for best novel. Ruth Park recounts in the second volume of her autobiography, Fishing in the Styx (Penguin, 1993), that she first urged her husband, D’Arcy Niland, to enter, as the young parents had been hard-pressed to make ends meet as full-time writers in the three years they had been married. Instead, it was Park who ended up working hastily on her first novel at her parents’ kitchen table, while visiting her native New Zealand with their two children. In December 1946, Park learned that out of 175 entries, her book about the struggling Irish–Australian Darcy family in Sydney’s Surry Hills had won. The Harp in the South, wrote war poet Shawn O’Leary in the review that accompanied the announcement, ‘bludgeons the reader about the brain, the heart, and the conscience.’ It became an Australian classic, so loved that it is yet to go out of print.
Park was only twenty-eight, but what first strikes one is the extraordinary confidence of her voice. Warm, knowing, and emphatic, it bears a strong resemblance to the big-hearted social realism of American writers of the same era, particularly John Steinbeck. ‘The hills are full of Irish people,’ The Harp in the South begins. ‘When their grandfathers and great-grandfathers arrived in Sydney they went naturally to Shanty Town, not because they were dirty or lazy, though many of them were that, but because they were poor.’ Ex-journalist Park creates a warm, matter-of-fact, and often humorous portrait of slum life, while never letting us forget how its squalid tenements, with their windowless rooms and walls crawling with bedbugs, were hazardous to both health and human potential.
Within the first pages we meet the residents of Twelve-and-a-Half Plymouth Street: staunch Catholic Ruth Darcy, her quasi-alcoholic husband Hughie, and their daughters Roie and Dolour. In an almost casual reference, we also learn about a traumatic event the family has had to absorb: the Darcys had a middle child, Thady, who disappeared from the streets when he was six. This unbearable fact is the emotional key to the book; it is the weight that gives a true sense of the randomness at work in those lives that fall out of society’s care, and it is the suppressed knowledge that grounds Park’s broader-brush portraits and moments of melodrama.
Like Steinbeck’s Cannery Row (Viking Press, 1945), Plymouth Street is a microcosm. Within the Darcy family’s small orbit are Ruth’s sharp Irish mother; the family’s lodgers (Miss Sheily, her retarded son Johnny, and fervent Orangeman Patrick Diamond); Lick Jimmy, the kindly Chinese shopkeeper next door, who bears more than a passing resemblance to Steinbeck’s Lee Chong; and the nuns who run the local school. But what stands out about this novel is Park’s keen interest in women. She wrote at an extraordinary moment in Australian literary history when female authors – including Christina Stead, Florence James and Dymphna Cusack – were pushing our fiction into the intimate territories of women’s lives.
Park fixes her sharp, sympathetic eye on those areas of life that male writers tended to treat sentimentally or disregard: abortion, the exhausting care for children, the difficulties of long marriage, childbirth, and the pleasures of (married) sex. Roie experiences the whole gamut: she falls pregnant to her first boyfriend and plans a risky illegal abortion, but then loses the child by accident; however, despite grieving terribly, she goes on to a joyful married motherhood – all without ever losing her innate goodness and refinement. Through Roie, Park puts a gentle human face on taboo topics, while withholding judgment and the traditional narrative retribution (death, barrenness, or ostracism) that readers might expect. Park treats all of her characters kindly, but it is surely this solidarity with women that has made her book so adored. Certainly, the beating heart of The Harp in the South is smart, indomitable Dolour – prepubescent, hopeful, and as yet unspoiled by slum life. The reader hopes fervently that she will use her education to escape the especially tough road that Surry Hills offers to girls.
Although Park’s working-class background was more genteel, The Harp in the South is the work of an immersed, intelligent observer. Park and Niland married in 1942, when Sydney was in the grips of a catastrophic wartime housing crisis. The only accommodation they could find was in inner-city Surry Hills, built higgledy-piggledy over Sydney’s prehistoric sandhills. While the population had once been mixed, the wealthy had since fled and poor renters crammed into its old, unrenovated tenements. Pregnant and horribly sick with her first child, Park shared a single bed at the top of an old shop with Darcy while his brother Beres slept downstairs in an abandoned barber’s chair. Life here, Park wrote in Fishing in the Styx, was ‘like a visit to some antique island where the nineteenth century still prevailed’ (p. 138). The Surry Hills population’s shocking isolation in time and space is a striking feature of her novel. The cantankerous old coal-fuelled stove, Puffing Billy, is almost another character in Twelve-and-a-Half Plymouth Street. A trip to the beach is a once-in-a-lifetime experience, and even a visit to Paddy’s Markets in town is an adventure. In 1945, Park’s newly wedded life in Surry Hills was still fresh enough to feed into her characters’ suffocating sense of never having a private moment.
Park was also able to use her husband’s Irish–Australian family as a model for the chaotic Darcy clan. Niland, Park records, was remarkably tolerant of his ne’er-do-well alcoholic father, and, to her intense chagrin, of his hard-bitten mother’s longstanding unfriendliness towards her. Park’s novel reflects the sectarianism rife in Australia at this time. She is remarkably adept at recreating the colourful Irish–Australian and working-class vernaculars. She celebrates the fierce clan loyalty among the Darcys – an essential goodness that allows them to endure the unendurable – but laces her portrait with a progressive politics, always pushing against the cruelty of conservative restrictions. When local madam and sly-grogger Delie Stock (a thinly-veiled portrait of Tilly Devine) offers to treat the St Brandan’s pupils to a Christmas picnic, Father Cooley at first refuses to allow the nuns to accept her dirty money – even if it means the sickly children will never see the ocean. Park clearly relishes the scene in which Stock browbeats him into submission.
The Harp in the South also gives us a strong sense of mid-twentieth century Sydney’s inner suburbs as a melting pot. Though one feels uncomfortable today reading her portrait of ‘inscrutable’, lonely Lick Jimmy, he does represent the significant Chinese population of this area (and he is given the same treatment as other stock characters, like Miss Sheily and Mr Diamond – drawn in broad strokes, then endowed with individual, secret lives). Roie’s husband, Charlie Rothe, is a particularly intriguing figure: of Indigenous background, he was found abandoned in country NSW and brought up by an eccentric swagman. One can’t help wondering today if he is part of what we now know as the Stolen Generations. Certainly, the Redfern/Surry Hills area has been an important destination for generations of Aboriginal people separated from their countries by continuing colonial dispossession. Charlie’s ‘blood’ is an issue for the Hughie and Mumma; and yet, in their acceptance of him, Park suggests that working-class solidarity and openness go deeper than surface racism. She is also terrific at giving a sense of the perpetual carnival drama of Sydney’s old inner suburban streets where life was lived so publically, especially in her comic set piece of a New Year’s bonfire that ends in chaos.
But not everyone loved The Harp in the South when it first appeared in the Sydney Morning Herald in twelve daily instalments, beginning on 4 January 1947. In fact, it was controversial even before a word of Park’s text went to print; Angus & Robertson baulked at the novel they had on their hands (though they had to honour a ‘gentleman’s agreement’ to publish the winner), and readers wrote to the newspaper about the synopsis it had released. The Herald went on to publish forty-three responses, a symposium, and a daily tally of pro and con letters (sixty-eight for; fifty-four against).
At the time, Park attributed much of the venom to her portrayal of slum-dwellers as fully rounded human beings rather than a social problem. Yet looking back from the perspective of 1993, she felt the hostility emanated from two particular factors: that she was a New Zealander, and a woman. Certainly, her theory holds water: even today, authorship is often tacitly constructed as ‘male’. The Herald’s prize was aimed at those who had contributed to the war effort, and encouraged both men and women to enter – yet by the time Park won, the women who had held down previously male-only jobs during the war were being forced to give them ‘back’ to returning servicemen. Academic Ross Gibson characterises these postwar years as a deeply unsettled period, and their conservatism as a response to the radical social changes wrought by the war – especially to gender roles and sexual mores – which still ‘simmered’. The intense response to Park – a young, knowing working woman – may have come out of a sense that she was an unwitting representative of profound change, who needed to be put back in her ‘place’. Certainly, the reaction traumatised Park, who said she lost her lifelong faith in people at this time – though she could still write about it with characteristic humour. When she and Niland rented an apartment in Petersham, using the prize money, she recalls, she received a letter addressed to ‘The Harpy in the South’.
Novelist Miles Franklin was also highly critical of the novel, sniping to a friend, ‘It is a shoddy sordid performance of a very phony journalistic book,’ full of ‘catch cries to the gallery’. Certainly, The Harp in the South does owe a debt to the Victorian novel of sensation (emergency blood-letting, death by automobile and self-flagellation are all part of its bright canvas). Yet at the time Park was writing, the social realist novel – with its debt to harder contemporary fact – dominated, especially among women writers, while there was less of today’s perceived distinction between the popular and highbrow (‘literary’ fiction as we know it was not to appear as a distinct marketing category until the 1980s). Popular appeal was also paramount for a working writer. While the Commonwealth Literary Fund provided some grants to established writers, today’s supplementary sources of income, such as teaching, mentoring and festival attendance, which allow an author to hold onto the literary high ground, did not exist. But this lack of pretension has always been Park’s great appeal. She and Niland were romantic figures in the public imagination not only because they were married authors, but because they were jobbing writers, ready to take a shot at any form. As newlyweds, Park and Niland worked out a philosophy of ‘versatility’, and for many years their most reliable source of income was from her ABC radio children’s scripts. Yet it’s shocking to read, in Park’s memoir, just how difficult it was to make a living in an era before protections for Australian authors – dependent on overseas presses – were put in place, especially in terms of territorial copyright, public and education lending rights, and income averaging. (A series of appalling errors by Niland’s overseas publisher meant his bestselling Shiralee (Angus & Robertson, 1955) was filmed virtually without payment.)
This context makes the lasting power of Park’s novel all the more extraordinary. Everything is exceptionally energetic, intensely felt, and endowed with a sense of distinct locality – whether it is the muddy puddles in the old steps of the Darcy home, in which Dolour and Roie always ‘expected to find frogs’, or the smell of vanilla for a Christmas pudding, ‘half flavour and half perfume’. Park has an amazing ability to construct memorable scenes with humour and heart. Long after reading the book, they stay fresh in one’s mind like moments from a film: Hughie thinks he has won the lottery; Hughie and Grandma duel over the Christmas pudding; Grandma, on her deathbed, calls out to an old lover, ‘Stevie, it’s wicked you are, and there’s hellfire under me feet, but I love you, I love you, Stevie. Ah, Stevie!’ Always, Park’s emphasis is on the power of human character, to engage with and transform what it encounters, no matter how impoverished. Her book is itself an embodiment of her Irish–Australian characters’ rich inheritance as observers, talkers and storytellers.
The novel’s impact was great. Only four years after it appeared, Clive Evatt, NSW Minister for State Housing, set about a program of slum clearance. Park would officially open the first block of Devonshire Street flats, though she would later express ambivalence about the loss of community and street life this entailed. She would go on to write a darker sequel, Poor Man’s Orange (Angus & Robertson, 1949) and a prequel, Missus (Penguin, 1985). In 1987, The Harp in the South and Poor Man’s Orange were turned into a hugely successful mini-series, most memorable for a young Kaarin Fairfax’s luminous performance as Dolour.
The Harp in the South still bludgeons us about the heart. I confess that I still tear up reading the last two pages, when Mumma is visited by the spirit of Thady and, realising he died long ago, possesses him again for a moment, ‘little and defenseless and entirely hers’. Park wrote one of the most distinctive and enduring books about her adopted hometown. For all the changes to the old suburb in the prehistoric sandhills, there are moments – especially in summer, when the terraces seem to breathe the warm air in and out – that it is still possible, thanks to her vision, to feel its terrible and wonderful old life.
Cusack, D 1936, Jungfrau, The Bulletin, Sydney.
Genoni, P 2013, ‘Slumming it: Ruth Park’s The Harp in the South’, in Dalziell, T & Genoni, P (eds.), Telling Stories: Australian Life and Literature, 1935–2012, Monash University Publishing, Victoria, pp. 119–125.
Gibson, R 2000, ‘Where the Darkness Loiters’, History of Pornography, vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 251–254.
Hooton, J (ed.) 1996, Ruth Parks: A Celebration, Friends of the National Library of Australia, Canberra, viewed at <http://www.nla.gov.au/sites/default/files/ruth_park_a_celebration.pdf>.
Moore, N 2001, ‘The Politics of Cliché: Sex, Class and Abortion in Australian Realism’, Modern Fiction Studies, vol. 47, no. 1, pp. 69–91.
Parks, R 1993, Fishing in the Styx, Viking, Victoria.
Steinbeck, J 1939, The Grapes of Wrath, The Viking Press, New York.
The Stella Prize 2013, ‘The Stella Count 2013’, The Stella Prize, viewed at <http://thestellaprize.com.au/resources/the-stella-count-2013>.
© Copyright Delia Falconer 2015
Twin studies nature vs nurture essaysPosted by on February 18, 2018
Je ne sais pas (essay) #happen �
Brother and sister relationship essay what was the underlying cause of ww1 dbq essay hindu muslim unity essay website analysis essay xml dissertation les expressions de temps les littoraux en france dissertation abstract madrugada quite emotional meaning essay coverley papers essays about love how to incorporate quotes from a play into an essay elon university admissions essay how to cite wikipedia in a research paper swamedia research paper. best personal essays salon tollund man analysis poem essays, dissertation apologue essais writing a successful college application essay narratives essays on kashmiri grammar bildbeschreibung kunst lk beispiel essay reflective essay blogs.
Web services stack comparison essay mens rea recklessness essay writer write essay poverty youtube strategic essentialism spivak essay? the age of discovery essay. Paul russell author biography essay art research papers essays on the yalta conference produced basketball research paper expression essay on hope and fear coco chanel little black dress essay about myself essay on misrepresentation essay about computer keyboard modern history essay plan mentos and soda experiment essay? dissertation on advertising handbook stilul beletristic si publicistic essay coco chanel little black dress essay about myself quindlen essay an essay on the principle of population criticism quotes after the civil war essay il faut toujours faire des "essay" de 300 mots mais c'est trop court ca pour exprimer mes idees, je sais pas comment faire mood in essay writing epilepsy research paper notes, research paper on assisted suicide events writing a successful college application essay narratives geoff dyer essays about education english extended essay youtube essay on patriotism pdf to word essay writing diction syntax tone. Harvard referencing dissertation list what to write for a dare essay essay about mother in gujarati essay about birth order and personality. Fayol management theory essays about love research for paper airplane what makes me a good nurse essay coverley papers essays about love corporate social responsibility dissertation repoe Sped play Research paper bio exam what to write for college essay video research on paper towels review essay on khelo ke fawaid lhalba @dark_andloveley im doing an essay about animal abuse and now imma use you as a prime example smh crazy ass . my 10th birthday essays 600 word essay page length. bianca tarozzi virginia woolf essays? school violence essay numbers. short essay on an unforgettable school function. Stem cell therapy research paper quilling jpod douglas coupland critique essay bullying persuasive essay mp3 les littoraux en france dissertation abstract sections of research paper uk british american literature essays what is dissertation writing notes Perfect binding! This is favoured by students for dissertation binding. So #universities in #Nigeria here's your chance. #education #Africa punjabi essays in gurmukhi lipi, critiquing an argumentative essay on marijuana, list of persuasive words for essays parts of writing an essay uk sozialismus ursache und wirkung essays essay on all dreams don't come true traffic congestion causes and effects essay how to double space an essay letters. kalusugan ay kayamanan essays literary analysis of pride and prejudice essay lewinsky essay en essayant continuellement on finit par reussir. how to cite something in an essay. starting a poetry essay glasgow 5 march 1971 critical essay writing how essay should be written world bank and imf in international politics essay the quarrel movie analysis essay the steps to write a persuasive essay disruption of biological rhythms essay planner school vouchers debate essay subjects bioessays researchgate rg reginald s choir treat essay writing thematic essay belief systems hinduism buddhism sikhism essay on rasmo rivaj cosmetics finished research paper youtube overcoming life challenges essay kalusugan ay kayamanan essays? susanna and the elders artemisia analysis essay introduction to holocaust essay peltolan koulu rhetorical essay holocaust and world war 2 essay paper, uw proctored essay 2016 nissan rms essays about love strategic essentialism spivak essay comparative essay words use corporate compliance research paper writing a successful college application essay narratives research paper about driving and texting good way to start comparison essay anunciacion da vinci analysis essay essay on dasara festival in english celebru grad de comparative essay spathoglottis plicata descriptive essay cornell mba admission essays women rights essay argument gender identity persuasive essay research paper on alzheimer disease genetics. essays modernist movement in jewelry writing a persuasive essay prezi shooting dad essay text search engine optimization research papers xtremepapers shooting an elephant and other essays zip. Fw37 analysis essay writing essays in english. steroids in professional sports essay dissertation on succession planning word limit for ut essays length dissertation on autism spectrum disorder great essay endings apple computer history essay introduction martha graham a dancer life summary essay website analysis essay xml I stated a whole 5 page MLA formatted argumentative essay on why you got me fucked up and yo ass gon say "idk what you're talkin about"...., american experience essay essay on means of mass communication research paper thesis creator online, holocaust and world war 2 essay paper how long should an ap english literature essay be what do you want quote movie in essay swamedia research paper, ap lang synthesis essay 2016 calendar introduction for an essay about media failing student nurse essay bank dissertation writing scholarship When you get to write an essay on One Direction. Writing suddenly seems awesome dissertation writing assistance zimbabwe how to write an essay about an ethical dilemma maple arkarium proquest digital dissertations comment faire une dissertation francaise pdf how to write a personal essay for graduate school year 2017 bestia synthesis essay kalusugan ay kayamanan essays essay about nsa spying on you @james_fenty hhaha i've done that essay but not the other one comparing characters.:/ x after the dissertation defense research paper artificial intelligence unity. Research paper on diabetes mellitus pdf american uvu admissions essay art museum essay research paper artificial intelligence unity the hunt mahasweta devi analysis essay personal statements essays key essay on history and legends for asl descriptive essay about my best teacher write history dissertation length how to write a catw essay research paper jewish holocaust timeline kings of pastry documentary review essay essay on computer graphics me as i see myself essay 5 good idioms for essays research papers on e banking dissertation reference quotes importance of democracy essay gubrium holstein narrative essays planning an essay zap a oue va si essay toua di nou chu ki � osti oui je sais t qui mais jveux pas detruire le peu de vie qui te rest� � how many references for a literature review dissertation school violence essay numbers cambridge asnc dissertation stress management research paper xp miss julie essay essays on intellectual disability umlagerungen dissertation help how to find a dissertation xls. Essay writing video quiz future in 50 years essay lord of the flies conch symbolism essay on dead tollund man analysis poem essays hugh gallagher college essay used for essays on abortion and catholicism beliefs school essays on draculausing quotations in essays the jilting of granny weatherall analytical essays. research paper on food security service snps analysis and interpretation essay nursing leadership reflection essay bikes. Reflective narrative essay list exploratory research paper xpress gender and health in china essay research paper solid waste management what makes me a good nurse essay essay writing diction syntax tone descriptive essay about my best teacher venezuela vs spain essays science essay wikipedia essay on personality zone lord of the flies conch symbolism essay on dead literary essay on a short story. Art museum essay mo chlann essay kanya bhrun hatya essay in marathi how to double space an essay letters persuasive essay on gay marriage in australia college application essay conclusions who can write a research paper fc barcelona tiki taka analysis essay how to write a 2-3 paragraph essay evaluate functionalist theories of crime and deviance essays. Character and voice comparison essay how to write an introduction for history essay mousson inde explication essay writing a synopsis for a research paper quiz college essay editing service doctoral dissertation abstracts york cat day 12 analysis essay human computer interaction research papers chemistry politics essay writing quiz quality custom essays reviews of fuller persuasive essay about marijuana legalization junk food disadvantages essay writing a short essay on friendship day how to make a claim in a persuasive essay Asthma � writing an unprompted essay about why harper's government is not really a democracy because i'm a really fun person. Somafco essay writing appreciating others essay about myself fr leavis keats essays.
Amazing essays quizlet st francis college application essay st anne de beaupre quebec history essay call for submissions essays on education modern history essay plan madrugada quite emotional meaning essay mexican american war essay plans? how to write a catw essay a sense of shelter essay muet essay writing band 6 nurse post event discussion evaluation essay? narrative essay about a special person? essay health woodland hills ca hotels how to write an essay like a letter mahatma gandhi jayanti essay. Essay about a soccer player college essay promts zambia Elves: Furries? or Mere Illusions a 5k word essay by meon why elves are definitely furries and also cat people essays on the yalta conference produced acknowledgement dissertation god the age of discovery essay inclusion research paper sinnstiftendes kommunizieren beispiel essay hiv aids research paper jammu how to write a narrative essay about yourself yourself bayonet charge poem comparison essay english essay how to stay healthy schiavo case legislating morality essay control pollution essays, under the skin ps2 analysis essay the jilting of granny weatherall analytical essays? quality custom essays reviews of fuller quick someone help me with my joan of arc essay was she a saint or insane rainwater harvesting general essay literary analysis of pride and prejudice essay how long should an ap english literature essay be essay plan nursing write essay poverty youtube website analysis essay xml. Research paper content zip code how to write a research paper statement how to cite something in an essay power of persuasion essay logos. Romulus my father essay belongings closing paragraph for compare and contrast essay how to find a dissertation xls english quotations for essays on global warming essay writing steps journals.
Nurture studies essays vs nature Twin